Increasingly in the Italian political debate is quoted Alexis de Tocqueville, and refers to the theme of «tyranny of the majority» treated in famous pages of Democracy in America of 1835. The essay aims to answer the questions: what is the true meaning Tocqueville gives the term «tyranny of the majority»? The conception of democracy they have in mind those who recall to Aristocratic Norman is the same as reflected in his work? In fact, the word democracy, in America, means the registration of the desires and needs of the people or the common people while in Europe, outlining the education and high moral and intellectual of the masses in achieving the collective good. Committed intellectuals, who call Tocqueville in support of their argument, tend to juxtapose the «tyranny of the majority» – the theme of Democracy in America of 1835 – to «the new kind of despotism» which appears instead in Democracy in America in 1840. In reality, these are two very different cases: first, the «tyranny of the majority», is, in fact, in terms of policy), the function¬ing of liberal democracy and the dangers which threaten it-the thesis of Aristotle and the Antiquity philosophers that many (the poor), once in government, threaten the freedom and property of the few (the rich); and the other, the new kind of despotism, is a theme of «metapolitics»: the diagnosis of a new civilization that is required at all, right and left, conservatives and progressives, and foretells, if anything, the perverse effects of the Welfare State. The essay does not enter the merits of the conceptions of the world in con¬flict but call attention to the need not to use the classics of political thought in the controversies that divide, as a physiological in self-respecting democracy, majority and opposition and above all, wants to be a call for a strict reading of what they «have really said».

Tocqueville e gli usi politici della tirannia della maggioranza

COFRANCESCO, DINO
2010-01-01

Abstract

Increasingly in the Italian political debate is quoted Alexis de Tocqueville, and refers to the theme of «tyranny of the majority» treated in famous pages of Democracy in America of 1835. The essay aims to answer the questions: what is the true meaning Tocqueville gives the term «tyranny of the majority»? The conception of democracy they have in mind those who recall to Aristocratic Norman is the same as reflected in his work? In fact, the word democracy, in America, means the registration of the desires and needs of the people or the common people while in Europe, outlining the education and high moral and intellectual of the masses in achieving the collective good. Committed intellectuals, who call Tocqueville in support of their argument, tend to juxtapose the «tyranny of the majority» – the theme of Democracy in America of 1835 – to «the new kind of despotism» which appears instead in Democracy in America in 1840. In reality, these are two very different cases: first, the «tyranny of the majority», is, in fact, in terms of policy), the function¬ing of liberal democracy and the dangers which threaten it-the thesis of Aristotle and the Antiquity philosophers that many (the poor), once in government, threaten the freedom and property of the few (the rich); and the other, the new kind of despotism, is a theme of «metapolitics»: the diagnosis of a new civilization that is required at all, right and left, conservatives and progressives, and foretells, if anything, the perverse effects of the Welfare State. The essay does not enter the merits of the conceptions of the world in con¬flict but call attention to the need not to use the classics of political thought in the controversies that divide, as a physiological in self-respecting democracy, majority and opposition and above all, wants to be a call for a strict reading of what they «have really said».
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11567/220678
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact